Cutting Through the Noise: 5 Marketing Moves Powered by Psychology

Navya Dokania
8 min readOct 14, 2024

--

Have you ever wondered how some brands cut through the noise and capture your attention almost so effortlessly, while others get lost in the background? The answers may be hiding in some of the fundamental yet often overlooked principles that drive consumer behavior. Let’s explore a fresh perspective on consumer psychology that could reshape the way we think about reaching our audience.

1. Problem/Need Recognition: Timing Is Everything

Imagine walking into a store and finding a product you didn’t even know you needed until that very moment. This is where marketers shine — spotting latent needs even before consumers do, and presenting solutions when most relevant, can dramatically shape behavior. In other words, you’re subconsciously creating a new need in your consumer’s mind with your marketing.

For example, let’s take privacy features on smartphones. Were people asking for fingerprint scanners or facial recognition before they were introduced? Not quite. But when they hit the market, they resonated with an unspoken need for security in an increasingly digital world.

Now let’s talk about the importance of timing here.

The first mobile phones to feature a fingerprint scanner, as per most sources, were the Pantech GI100 launched in 2004, and Toshiba G500 and G900, introduced in 2007. However, this was a classic case of “right tech, wrong time”. Back then, most users didn’t even bother setting a passcode to protect their phones because they didn’t believe they had to. Understandably so, as phones at the time held far less sensitive information ­­­ — contact lists, maybe some blurry pictures, and eventually some social media apps. Hence, it didn’t ‘cut through the noise’.

With other companies launching swipe-based scanners and similar technologies in the meantime, it wasn’t until Apple’s iPhone 5S in 2013, with its fingerprint scanner, that this need and the feature actually caught mainstream. Why? Because the rise of mobile banking, private messaging, and the growing sensitivity of personal data on our devices created an urgent need for better security. Not to mention, digital threats and data breaches from the early 2010s ranked among the top ten all-time breaches (Infosec, 2014), targeting personal information. This backdrop highlighted the increasing demand for secure authentication methods, making features like fingerprint scanners a must-have in such vulnerable digital landscapes.

So, how can you anticipate the needs of your customers before they’ve realized it them themselves? That’s where innovation meets intuition, but timing is everything.

2. Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs: Going Beyond the Basics

Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs Pyramid

Here’s a truth bomb — functional benefits aren’t enough anymore. Consumers don’t just want products that work; they want to feel something, to become part of something bigger. That’s where Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs comes in; a psychological theory that explains human motivation through a pyramid of five levels. It explains how people evolve from fulfilling basic needs to pursuing deeper desires such as belongingness and self-fulfillment.

But, how does this apply to marketing?

In marketing, understanding where a product fits in this hierarchy helps businesses tap into deeper emotional desires beyond functional benefits, resonating with consumers on a more profound level. Imagine a fitness app that gives you workout routines (the functional need). That’s cool, but what if that app also connects you with a community, celebrates your milestones, and encourages you to feel like you’re on a life-changing journey? Well, now we’re talking value. It’s about blending the emotional impact with functional solutions to create something meaningful.

MyFitnessPal app

For example, one of the highest grossing fitness apps — MyFitnessPal, allows users to set their own fitness goals (weight loss, muscle gain, or even maintenance), and monitor progress over time. It breaks these larger goals into smaller, achievable milestones, giving users a constant sense of accomplishment. How does it do this? MyFitnessPal encourages users to log meals and exercises daily by tracking “streaks” (similar to Snapchat) of consecutive days you’ve logged in and entered data. As the streak count grows, it motivates users to keep the momentum going along with its motivational push notifications like “You’re almost there! Just 200 more steps to hit your daily goal!” It then rewards users with digital badges for milestones, fostering a sense of progress and accomplishment. The app also creates a supportive community where users share tips, celebrate achievements, which subconsciously enhances accountability, and healthy competitiveness, reinforcing positive change. MyFitnessPal goes beyond just calorie counting by integrating with other fitness apps and devices like Apple Health, allowing users to monitor various aspects of their health, making the experience feel like a comprehensive, life-changing journey rather than just a short-term diet.

Ask yourself: Is your brand just solving problems, or is it changing lives?

3. Risk and Reward: The Power of Consumer Stakes

As a marketer, risk is actually your friend. Why? Because when consumers feel something is at stake, they pay attention. Marketers can use this to their advantage by creating a sense of urgency or scarcity.

Take fast fashion giant Zara. Instead of over-producing every clothing item, they focus on achieving a golden equation between a just-in-time production and just-in-case consumption. They release limited quantities but of different items on a more frequent basis. This promotes their consumers, particularly women, to buy things they like even if they don’t require it immediately due to a just-in-case mentality: “I don’t need this now, but what if it’s not available later?”

This is more than FOMO (Fear of Missing Out); it’s about aligning your supply with consumer psychology, and in turn making it your marketing strategy.

How can you make them feel like your product is exclusive? Or a limited-time piece? This strategy drives engagement, loyalty, and even impulsive buying.

4. The Paradox of Choice: Less Is More

Do you ever feel overwhelmed by the sheer number of options in the grocery store? From choosing between dozens of cereal brands to deciding on the perfect pasta sauce, the endless variety can leave you stuck. This is the paradox of choice — while having options is usually beneficial, too many can lead to decision fatigue.

If you’re offering your audience a long list of choices, you might actually be pushing them away. This is because more choices require more mental effort to evaluate and compare options, which can lead to anxiety, dissatisfaction, and a decreased likelihood of making a purchase. On the other hand, given the purchase has been made, consumers may experience post-purchase regret, questioning whether they made the best choice given the the overwhelming number of alternatives that were available to them. Narrow down your focus, curate your offerings, cut through the noise. The secret to satisfaction lies in simplicity, not in abundance.

Additionally, effective communication is crucial in helping guide consumers through their decision-making process. Providing clear information, comparisons, and recommendations can help alleviate the burden of choice and facilitate more confident decision-making.

Food for thought: Could fewer options actually lead to more conversions?

5. Theory of Reasoned Action: Influence Intentions, Shape Behavior

The Theory of Reasoned Action tells us that consumers are rational actors driven by specific intentions; and an individual’s intention to perform a behavior is influenced by their own pre-existing attitudes and societal influences. In marketing terms, this means your campaigns need to tap into both individual desires and a collective approval.

A sustainable clothing brand isn’t just selling eco-friendly fashion — it’s promoting a lifestyle aligned with social values. Why do many eco-conscious brands highlight customer stories, celebrity endorsements, and certifications from trusted organizations? They’re not just selling clothes; they’re selling social proof. Consumers want to feel that their choice reflects widely accepted social values of “caring about the planet”. This taps directly into the theory of reasoned action, where decisions are influenced by the desire for social validation and alignment with personal beliefs.

Outside the sustainability world, a great example is Nike’s “Just Do It” campaigns, which taps into individuals’ desires to achieve personal empowerment and growth. By aligning their messaging with widely accepted social norms like athletic achievement and personal empowerment, Nike influences consumers to not only buy their products but also to feel that purchasing Nike reflects their own commitment to self-improvement. What’s most interesting is that Nike’s ads rarely ever mention their products at all. Instead, their focus has been on emotional communication, in which they design each ad to elicit specific feelings and needs in the consumers that only Nike’s products can meet. Their messaging doesn’t just sell products — it sells an identity.

It does this by playing up the classic tale of a hero/winner who strives to overcome hardship before eventually winning against an enemy. However, here there isn’t a literal enemy. I think this form of a communication is great because Nike takes this analogy to a far more relatable level, where it directly speaks to your inner hero. The ‘enemy’ is the voice in your head telling you, “You can’t”. To that, Nike says: “Just do it.”, positioning their products as tools for success. To relate it back to ‘reasoned action’, they’re reshaping their consumer’s pre-existing attitudes to create an intention or reason to perform an action, translating into a purchase thereafter.

Nike’s 2018 Colin Kaepernick Ad

One of Nike’s communications that I’ve found particularly interesting was the one featuring Colin Kaepernick, who was fired from the NFL due to his protest against police brutality towards African Americans. While Nike did not make an official remark about the protest or their position, their all black and white ad featuring Colin’s face, symbolized Nike’s beliefs on how racial colour doesn’t matter and made clear their stance in this protest. Simple words- “Believe in something. Even if it means sacrificing everything”, resonated deeply with societal values of justice and courage, tapping into the collective belief in fighting for what’s right, regardless of the cost. Although this ad created great controversy, it cut through the noise and Nike saw a 1,400% surge in social media activity and earned $6 billion in sales (Williams, 2018).

This approach, in line with this theory, influences individual consumer behavior by aligning Nike with personal and societal beliefs, reinforcing the brand’s connection with its audience beyond functional benefits.

Hence,

effective marketing is more than flashy ads and catchy slogans. It’s about understanding the psychology behind consumer choices and influencing behaviors in subtle, yet powerful ways. Are you just solving problems, or are you changing how your audience thinks, feels, and acts? In my opinion, success lies in balancing innovation with intuition, scarcity with strategy, and choices with clarity.

So, what’s your next move as a marketer? Are you ready to cut through the noise and tap directly into the minds of your consumers?

--

--

Navya Dokania

Contemplative Creativity, featuring the journey through the mind & heart of a 22-year-old—one idea at a time.